Stranded with All-stars is the first full-all-stars season in Stranded. It featured players from the first three seasons all separated onto three tribes. The three tribes were separated by their respective season: a tribe consisting of all Bolivia members, one of all Aruba members and one of all Peru members. In a twist, only one tribe won Immunity and the other two faced tribal council. However, the two people voted off were not out of the game, they went into banishment. The leader of the tribe that won the very next Immunity Challenge would choose which of the two would be voted off, and which one would then join their tribe. This resulted in saving a majority of the easy targets and the huge characters of their previous seasons. Namely, Lill, who was hated by her original season was unanimously voted off and subsequently chosen to return, much to her archrival Amanda’s chagrin. In a twist, Bolivia was lacking their most notorious member, Joel, the winner. As a replacement, Colleen, the most popular winner from pre-stranded days was cast in his place. From day one, Colleen was both beloved and feared; as everyone knew her likability could result in yet another win.

Still, she found a close ally in Rudy who protected her. In a twist on what was expected, Gretchen was rational and Rudy’s hatred for her began to show cracks. Shane and Judd were closer than ever as they neared the merge and found a new ally in Kelly. Unfortunately, Kelly and Judd became early targets leaving the popular Shane to fend for his self. Rudy along with his allies Misty and Colleen furthered themselves. Shortly Rudy established himself as King when he was calling the shots on who left and when. Since everyone trusted King Rudy, he used that to his advantage and quickly cut the throats of Colleen and Misty who trusted him fully. Christa made an impressive run in the game with her Hidden Immunity Idol and managed to make the final five despite having few allies. In the end, Rudy finally got his comeuppance after stabbing everyone in the back when Courtney, Shane and Melinda voted him off just before the finals. In the end, the curmudgeon Courtney outwitted and outlasted everyone to become the last person Stranded with All-stars.